Skip to main content

Data vs Ideology - what works for the poor?

Nate Silver –the man who challenged American political pundits to follow math- not their guts. I might sound full of pride- but this is probably that time when all researchers are probably finding some Nate Silver in themselves.   

Picture Source: Vanity Fair

We study all sort of financial behavior of the poor- and when we present our findings, we attain our shares of tributes as well as hostilities …!We like it or not:  the fact is that our pundits from the development sector ( I am including practitioners, policymakers, donors, and researchers) accept our research findings as long as they match their ideologies. At times, when I am very pessimistic about my own work as a researcher, I develop this feeling that this whole idea of what is working for the poor has always been about someone’s ideologies- be it some visionary’s or donor’s or activist’s ideas- what product works for the poor has never been about science and math- and probably that is the reason we have never been able to alleviate poverty.

Look at the microfinance sector in India. While microfinance was on its acclivitous path, we had pundits endorsing the commercialization and profit in microfinance without understanding the impact and values of different models on the poor. The series of unprecedented suicides in Andhra Pradesh allowed the influx of criticism toward the sector from all over the world. Without understanding what the alternatives are for the poor in the absence of microfinance, the state of Andhra Pradesh that let microfinance to flourish in the past passed the AP Microfinance Ordinance 2010 that greatly restricted the microfinance operations in AP. Who suffered through all this- probably microfinance clients- the poor!

It is not the story of microfinance programme only. Even other intervention programmes for the poor are implemented without any scientific verification. I am not entirely blaming our distinguished practitioners and service providers for it. The research community in India has not developed as rapidly as the sector itself. Many research studies conducted in India are not even based on observations made in practice and, in return, implementation of any development programs is not based on research findings. However, even when we are ready with our rigorously conducted research findings, our Babus have some reservations about our findings. This has resulted in the loss of opportunities for synergies between policy and research.
We researchers believe that our research can clarify many questions and contribute to decision making process of policymakers, however, we get a rude shock when we realize that the direct influence of research evidence on policy and practice is mostly tempered by our pundits' own experimental knowledge and belief. It has been our struggle to achieve our goal of translating our research into practice. Hopefully, our continuous and sustained dialogue with policymakers and practitioners will one day increase the usage of research based evidence in policy. Meanwhile, there is no harm in receiving some inspiration from Nate Silver who defeated all pundits this election season…! There is still some hope that someday pundits will listen to us as well….!


  1. Dear Deepti, on a lighter note....Happy Diwali!!!!!

  2. Interesting piece!


Post a Comment

Popular Posts

Vocationalisation of education in India: Current Scenario, Key Challenges and New directions

“Every handicraft has to be taught not merely mechanically as is done today, but scientifically. This is to say, the child should learn the why and wherefore of every process.” - Gandhi’s Philosophy of Education

The greatest challenge in Indian education system today is to provide skill based education to the youth. This is exacerbated by a mismatch in demand and supply for the skilled workforce. The penetration of vocational education and training remains poor not only in rural areas, but also in urban regions where there is a higher installed capacity to impart the same. This post is an attempt to make the readers understand the need of vocational education in India. Also, this is an attempt to summarise a few recommendations on the same. 
A recent survey (61st round) conducted by the NSSO found that:

1. The percentage of population that completed primary education was 70%, but less than 10% went on to complete a graduation course and above. Almost 97% of individuals in the age bracket…

Rockstar of Financial Inclusion: Business Correspondent Model of India

About Author:  Jatinder Handoo is a social business enthusiast and a branchless banking practitioner. Currently works at FINO PayTech Ltd and is based out of Mumbai. He is reachable at
India is a hot bed of financial exclusion. A country which houses nearly 16% of the global population  has more than 65% of its people outside the formal financial system (Global Findex 2012). The Indian banking system has adopted multiple approaches to make universal financial inclusion a reality right from early days Indian post-independence banking system. Be it bank nationalization in 1969 or formation of Regional Rural Banks. Formation of NABARD or fostering microfinance through Bank-SHG linkage programme in early 90’s. A shimmering ray hope was rekindled with the growth of JLG based microfinance, however later studies made it clear that the model is credit led, concentrated predominately in the southern region of India thus could not be seen as painting complete financial…

A Platform for Knowledge - Enabling people to learn ..

I received a rather interesting link/website via my email today. The link read as MR University and all I could think of was, "Ok, this must be another website portal of some university or college". Well, on clicking the link and looking through the contents of the site, I was pleasantly surprised. The site is an online education portal or platform that allows users or teachers to upload short videos on topics or lessons they wish to impart. First topic that I come across is Development Economics.
The intent of the website is eloquently put out by the two economists, Tyler Cowen and Alex Tabarrok in the intro video. What started as a blog focusing on economics and its various implications in understanding why things are the way they are around us, has now an interesting addition. A video portal titled MRUniversity or Marginal Revolution University that focuses on online education with subjects pertaining to economics. It brought back to my mind,…