Skip to main content

Analyzing the BC Model (Part III) Why isn't it Working? - Assymetry Between the Model and Agent/Client Needs


In our first post in this series, we discussed the key advantages of the BC model and the reasons that it should succeed as an apex financial inclusion tool. However, as we stated in our second post, the model has not been performing up to its expectations since its inception in 2006. Along with low usage patterns of No-Frills accounts, the second major problem faced has been an asymmetry between the needs of agents and clients and the procedures followed by BCs and banks. These problems are specific to each tier in the BC model, namely the BC itself, the agents and the clients.

Agent Problems

(i)       Financial Viability

The sustainability of the BC model is dependent on the volume of transactions. These volumes are extremely low, as we discussed in our previous post.  A revenue-cost analysis in an upcoming CMF study found that urban CSPs are making a profit while rural CSPs are losing money. This is because transaction volumes are higher in urban, remittance heavy areas.

Agents are also struggling to make a profit as the current commission structure is inadequate to cover agents’ costs. Tiered commission structures usually remunerate the agents a percentage of the amount transferred or facilitated. The advantage of that would be agents targeting clients who make higher volume transactions while they would be less willing to serve clients who make low volume transactions, which is the primary focus of the BC model itself. CMF’s research study cites that a flat commission structure on the other hand could give agents an incentive to do artificial transactions, crediting and debiting accounts by the same amount and making money off the transaction itself.

(ii)     Cash Management and Liquidity

The most prominent problems faced by the agents are related to cash management and liquidity issues.  BCs typically transfer as much money to agents as the security deposit paid by them. However, there are typically large gaps between deposit and withdrawals due to location specific characteristics, such as rural areas being withdrawal heavy due to incoming remittances. BCs expect their agents to use their own cash to make withdrawals if they do not get sufficient cash through deposits. As a result, agents often end up facing a liquidity crunch, which leaves them unable to provide withdrawals, risking their reputation as well as that of the bank. However, if cash collection facilities were to be provided by BCs, they would add to the cost of operations for the BC.

(iii)   Operational Issues

Agents have reported issues with the base branch claiming branch officials restrict agents to opening only 5 accounts per day and even simple requests to display account numbers on cards given to clients take months to be processed. Technical glitches faced by agents also hinder BC work, ranging from improper functioning of the bank server to other software glitches.

Many agents stated that the BC channel should serve multiple diverse products to fulfill the needs of the clientele.



Biometric registration of a BC client (Photocredit: NY Times)
Client Issues

The CMF study found that clients engaged in services, agriculture and allied activities maintained the highest balances in their NFAs. Labourers on the other hand, maintained the smallest balances and carried out the least number of transactions.
The two primary problems identified by clients included agent inactivity and lack of knowledge about the product.

(i)       One-fourth of the clients of a particular BC said that the agent in charge of collecting their deposits never visited them. In other areas accounts were opened but no agents were appointed for the clients. 

(ii)     24% of the clients surveyed cited poor services or lack of information about the account and its features as the primary reason for inactivity.  

Showcasing the dire need for financial education, some clients in the survey used NFAs solely for remittances and were not even aware of the fact that they could use these accounts to save!

Challenges faced by BCs

The Business Correspondents face problems from every single tier in the organizational model. According to an upcoming CMF study on the financial viability of the BC model, these include:

Many of the BCs in the study believed that costs and risks involved in cash management are entirely and unfairly borne by the BC or its agents with little or no contributions from the bank. Agents sometimes retain cash if they anticipate future withdrawals but this makes it difficult for the BC to transfer the balance to other agents and creates a shortage of cash in the settlement account of the BC. In the absence of overdraft facilities, agents as well as BCs don’t have enough cash to facilitate withdrawals and settle the amount with the principle bank at the same time.

These issues, combined with the inactivity of No-Frills accounts have contributed to the poor performance of the BC model so far. In order to be successful, the model must fulfill the RBI’s financial inclusion goals while ensuring financial viability of the model for BCs. Our next post in this series will discuss policy recommendations to improve the functioning of the model and improve its performance in the long run.

Comments

  1. Agents sometimes retain cash if they anticipate future withdrawals .

    ReplyDelete
  2. Opening an account = financial inclusion, when will this equation change ? when will efcctive use be a part of FI definition ? when will RBI find a complementing role between SHGs in the FI initiative ?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts

Vocationalisation of education in India: Current Scenario, Key Challenges and New directions

“Every handicraft has to be taught not merely mechanically as is done today, but scientifically. This is to say, the child should learn the why and wherefore of every process.” - Gandhi’s Philosophy of Education

The greatest challenge in Indian education system today is to provide skill based education to the youth. This is exacerbated by a mismatch in demand and supply for the skilled workforce. The penetration of vocational education and training remains poor not only in rural areas, but also in urban regions where there is a higher installed capacity to impart the same. This post is an attempt to make the readers understand the need of vocational education in India. Also, this is an attempt to summarise a few recommendations on the same. 
A recent survey (61st round) conducted by the NSSO found that:

1. The percentage of population that completed primary education was 70%, but less than 10% went on to complete a graduation course and above. Almost 97% of individuals in the age bracket…

Rockstar of Financial Inclusion: Business Correspondent Model of India

About Author:  Jatinder Handoo is a social business enthusiast and a branchless banking practitioner. Currently works at FINO PayTech Ltd and is based out of Mumbai. He is reachable at jatinder.handoo@fino.co.in
India is a hot bed of financial exclusion. A country which houses nearly 16% of the global population  has more than 65% of its people outside the formal financial system (Global Findex 2012). The Indian banking system has adopted multiple approaches to make universal financial inclusion a reality right from early days Indian post-independence banking system. Be it bank nationalization in 1969 or formation of Regional Rural Banks. Formation of NABARD or fostering microfinance through Bank-SHG linkage programme in early 90’s. A shimmering ray hope was rekindled with the growth of JLG based microfinance, however later studies made it clear that the model is credit led, concentrated predominately in the southern region of India thus could not be seen as painting complete financial…

A Platform for Knowledge - Enabling people to learn ..

I received a rather interesting link/website via my email today. The link read as MR University and all I could think of was, "Ok, this must be another website portal of some university or college". Well, on clicking the link and looking through the contents of the site, I was pleasantly surprised. The site http://www.mruniversity.com/ is an online education portal or platform that allows users or teachers to upload short videos on topics or lessons they wish to impart. First topic that I come across is Development Economics.
The intent of the website is eloquently put out by the two economists, Tyler Cowen and Alex Tabarrok in the intro video. What started as a blog focusing on economics and its various implications in understanding why things are the way they are around us, has now an interesting addition. A video portal titled MRUniversity or Marginal Revolution University that focuses on online education with subjects pertaining to economics. It brought back to my mind,…